Third Spaces Aren't Enough, We Need Everywhere to be Free Right Now
The lack of third spaces in my city is becoming more obvious and inconvenient to me. The businesses here have taken capitalism a step further than smaller cities by not only refusing to provide space for people who aren’t paying customers to sit but also wanting to swiftly kick out customers who purchased food and who now want to eat it in their establishment. You want a table AND chairs, you peasant? You want to sit quietly and eat your sandwich while the space you would be taking up could be used by someone waiting in line for their sandwich? Who gave you the nerve?
Everywhere I go, I feel like I’m being ushered through a lineup and then expected to pay and either leave immediately and to take my food home, or to awkwardly pull my food out of its bag and attempt to eat it standing by the front doors, getting in everyone’s way. These places now exist solely to provide food and not a place to consume it. I feel like I’m surrounded by food pick up windows that were once small restaurants.
Recently, on a night where I was meeting up with my parents and their friend to see a play, I felt the strain of capitalism against my shoestring budget more than ever. My day started by going into work which wasn’t the worst part of my disdain at living in a capitalist nightmare but it certainly didn’t help. At lunch I texted my colleague/friend the address to the work event I had invited him to (forced him to go to with me.) He works in IT and I pitched the party to him as a way to learn more about Cybersecurity threats to our workplace in 2025, even though it wasn’t clear to me that these would even be covered in the presentations being put on by one of the vendors my workplace uses. I had to be there to shake hands and introduce myself (no I didn’t), and I wanted a familiar face accompany me to buffer the awkwardness of going up to random strangers and asking them what brought them to this event when they were clearly just invited like I was. He agreed, but only on the pretense that the event was being held at the same venue as it was last year and that the catering for this venue had recently gone through some improvements and now all the food being served was delicious. For mass produced hors d’oeuvres, the tasters that I had at last year’s event filled me up spiritually as well as physically. He was sold, mainly because I was so insistent.
Although it was his day off, he showed up to work on time to pick me up so we could walk over to the event together. We ate as much as our stomachs could allow, I had a small glass of free wine and we decided to leave before the room emptied out of everyone except the people who were throwing the event or working there. I wanted to kill some time before meeting my parents and their friend, Jan, to see a play they had bought us tickets for that came highly recommended. It was 5:30pm and I needed to be at the theatre before 8pm. It was a 30 minute walk but the weather wasn’t being cooperative and it was raining/snowing in big wet drops of condensation. I figure I would need a drink or dinner to keep me warm for the walk.
When my friend and I left the building, I suggested we go next door to the Earl’s that most certainly would be busy. Despite this busyness, I figured it would likely have a nice window-facing table that we could sit at, people watch a thousand white men in navy suits, and eat sliders in. I thought wrong. When we got to the host stand, they said that it would be an hour and a half wait. On a random Wednesday in December. Maybe they were hosting holiday parties. We thanked them and promptly left and tried to find somewhere indoors that would take us because it was raining/snowing out.
My friend suggested we find someplace cheap in the underground pathway leading to the subway and I vetoed this idea because everything down there closes at 5 or is depressing because of their lack of windows. We were stuck where we were and had no idea where to hang out, gossip, and eat. It bothered me because we were in the heart of downtown, in this enormous city, without options that wouldn’t make us wait for over an hour. Even though we were open to spending money there, there were simply too many people and functions to accommodate. We felt confused and disheartened. I don’t want to have to spend money to be able to spend time with my friend outside of work. I want there to be places we can go, that are indoors, and that are chill.
We finally accepted that the only comfortable spot we could loiter and talk shit in was the lobby of a nearby office building. Not our office building, someone else’s. It was bustling and filled with people leaving for the night and UberEats drivers dropping off food for people refusing to go home. We spent half an hour complaining about pretty much all of our mutual friends and then I decided that it would be a good time to set off on the 30 minute walk to the area where the theatre was. I walked my friend to where he was going on the subway line, and continued my journey in the cold and dark. It rained and I was wearing a wool coat I bought myself in 2013 which was, understandably, falling apart at the seams. I was ill-prepared for the weather but took pride in the fact that I’d be saving myself 3.25$ in subway fare.
As I got closer to the neighbourhood where the theatre was, I started to get excited about the prospect of the Christmas market that was being held there and how it had free entry during the week. From Thursday to Sunday, I believe they have a 15$ entry fee to the market. Regardless, I wasn’t paying that. When I got to the winter festival area, I walked in and immediately clocked how busy it was despite the rain. People were lining up at most of the outdoor kiosks and waiting to order crepes, waffles, hot chocolates, beer, mulled wine, and poutine. The fried food stands outnumbered any of the others. It was cold but people could at least pay 15$ for something to warm them up. I also noticed that each of these food stands didn’t have anywhere to stop and eat at. No high top tables to stand around, no chairs to sit and balance your boat of food on. People were expected to just stand next to those in line waiting their turn to order.
I had made mental plans to buy a hot chocolate, assuming incorrectly that there may be tables to sit where they sold it. I had forgotten what the store looked like on the inside. I was met with a short lineup that was organized by a rope indicating where people should go to for what (wait here to order and pay, wait here for your drink, and get out if you’re not about to drop 10$ on hot chocolate, also close the door when you leave because the wind is making everyone inside cold.)
The chocolate store was brightly lit and welcoming in the sense that the people who worked there were nice and they were making hot chocolate for everyone. It was not welcoming in that there were two benches to sit on that seemed shoehorned into the far back of the store and both were filled with people quietly sipping their hot chocolate and taking photos. I wondered where I would go once I got my drink, which was ready almost as soon as I had finished paying the woman at the register.
There was still an hour to wait until the show started but I approached the theatre to scope it out. I also saw two people inside the theatre lobby dressed up as Santa and Mrs. Claus taking photos at a makeshift photo wall with little kids, and a sign on the door that politely asked you to not bring outdoor food and beverages inside. I felt the need to down my hot chocolate immediately so I could escape from the cold but then also didn’t want to deal with the crowds surrounding Santa and his wife.
I tried to pick a store that wouldn’t mind my presence despite having hot, brown liquid in a cup. The nearest store I could see was a sock store. There were two people working and chatting at the till and a couple browsing the wide selection of socks. I picked up a pair of socks closest to the door and my movement caused the sock rack to destabilize and fall off the wall mounting. While I tried to hold the socks in one hand, the hot chocolate in the other, I attempted to picked the rack up off the floor. One of the women at the till came over to help me. I decided to hold onto the socks as a 28$ penance for my clumsiness. I don’t regret the purchase because they’re very warm and comfortable. Even though it was a nice purchase, I really only bought them because of the guilt I felt for my slip up and my appreciation for the women who didn’t side-eye me for bringing hot chocolate into their charming sock store. I left and went next door to a dispensary.
At the dispensary, I bought sleep gummies in cash to take before the show started. I had seen the show the year prior and had thoroughly enjoyed it. I assumed that the weed gummies would make me pay better attention to any plot points that I had missed the first time.
As I finished my hot chocolate outside, I heard a security guard berate some teenagers for smoking weed that they didn’t even have. They told him that it wasn’t theirs and that they didn’t know where the smell was coming from and he ushered them away from the front doors, saying that the smell was overpowering and causing people to become uncomfortable. This whole interaction made me uncomfortable, and not because I was about to smash some pre-play weed candy, but because even the innocent children he was accosting weren’t allowed to stand around outside the theatre’s entrance, because the security guard incorrectly attributed the smoking to them. I wanted justice for the teens.
When I entered the theatre, I noticed that although the crowd of Santa Claus fans had dissipated slightly, there were still way too many people standing around for it to be comfortable. Each chair and flat surface was sat and covered with someone or their items. I knew there was a bathroom in the back of the theatre so my first move was to go there to take off my coat and pee. I knew that this would only kill 5 minutes tops but I had run out of ideas and ways to waste time before the start of the show. While I peed, I texted my parents and their friend that I had arrived and was looking for a spot to settle in for the next thirty minutes before the show started. I told them to take their time getting there and that there was no need to rush because I was alone and it wasn’t fun there. As I exited the bathroom, I saw a small, makeshift sign pointing to a lounge for ticket holders. Well, I was a ticket holder. I mean my dad had purchased my ticket but he was definitely going to show up at some point and I’m sure he had emailed me a copy. I approached the lounge with caution and doubt and a young server came out from its entrance. I asked him if I was allowed to be there and he said “Yes, of course.” So I walked in.
The lounge was a recycled theatre, empty except for the server and a woman standing behind a bar that doubled as a stand for her computer. She ignored me the whole time I was there. There were about 10 tables and chairs and a wall full of theatre seats so I sat in one in the front row. I watched as a couple of stragglers came in from the cold, like me, confused about whether they were allowed to be there. Some bought drinks and snacks from the bar. Some spent no money. We all were welcomed into this third space where we were free to chat quietly or look at our phones like I was.
While I waited for my parents and their friend to show up, I felt grateful to have found this magical place where I could be without feeling pressure to purchase anything else that night.
My parents and their friend arrived shortly after and we proceeded to chat in the theatre seats until it was time to take our actual seats in the theatre where the play was showing. At the end of the night, my parents drove me home.
At my part-time job’s workplace at a café, it has benches and tables for people to use at will. Some people sit there alone and finish their food only to leave immediately afterwards. Some people linger and talk with their friends after their food is finished. Some people leave as soon as they’ve purchased their food. While I understand the frustration of serving people close to closing time and praying that they’ll leave before you have to ask them to politely, most of the time I just appreciate the company. I’ll do dishes in the back, attempting to eavesdrop on their conversations, unable to hear what they’re saying over the commercial faucet. Knowing they’re there makes me feel safe and comfortable, even if we aren’t interacting. Moreover, people very seldom stay past an hour until closing time and if they do, it’s because I know them.
The energy I want to enforce at the place where I work is that people are free to stay if they want to. They don’t have to leave as soon as they’re finished their food or drinks. They don’t have to leave if their friend leaves, and they don’t have to spend money to take up space in the establishment. It can be hard as a consumer to not feel like you’re being taken advantage of by businesses. And small business owners are at odds because they, too, have a difficult time sustaining their profits while paying rent in an expensive city. In turn, they feel like they must be extra cautious about providing too much product, space, or employee time to their customers. This ongoing game of who is capitalizing off who the most ultimately makes me sad even though it may be self-inflicted.
When I asked one of my bosses at the café, she said that doesn’t feel the lack of third spaces as much as I do but understands the dueling sides of my problem. We talk often about how to provide a pleasant space for customers and how to have them stick around when they want to and spend money to keep the business afloat. What I hope for is more spaces like the theatre lounge, where anyone can sit down in while they wait for their show to start. They’re welcome to enjoy their friends’ companies without the pressure to stand, pay for food they don’t want, or be a burden to the business owner by existing there without spending money.